Gen AI: Unpacking the Differences Between Open-Ended and Close-Ended AI Tasks

During the most recent European Gen AI event held on May 8th, a significant topic of discussion was the differentiation between open-ended and close-ended tasks within AI technologies. These classifications are fundamental in shaping how we develop, interact with, and leverage artificial intelligence across various sectors. This post aims to shed light on these distinctions, explaining their implications for both developers and users, and illustrating how these tasks are implemented and evaluated.

‍

Why is it important to make a distinction?

Understanding the difference between open-ended and close-ended tasks is crucial for several reasons:

• Development Focus: For developers, knowing the type of task helps in choosing the right algorithms, data, and evaluation metrics.
• User Expectations: It sets the right expectations for users. For example, users can expect definitive answers from close-ended tasks and a range of possibilities from open-ended tasks.
• Innovation and Application: It drives innovation by pushing the boundaries of what AI can achieve in various domains, whether it's generating creative content or making precise judgments.

‍

Differences between close-ended and open-ended tasks

Close-Ended Tasks:These involve specific, bounded outputs where the AI system is expected to produce a definite answer. Examples include:

• Classification: Assigning labels to data points, like spam detection in emails.
• Detection/Scoring: Identifying entities or assessing qualities within data, such as detecting faces in images or scoring essay responses.
• Named Entity Recognition (NER): Identifying and classifying key information in text, like names, organizations, and locations.

Open-Ended Tasks:These tasks are characterized by their generative nature, often producing a variety of possible outputs. Examples include:

• Text Generation: Creating content, such as composing emails, generating reports, or even writing stories.

In Between – The Hybrid Tasks:Some tasks straddle the boundary between open and close-ended, involving elements of both generation and decision-making:

• Summarization: Condensing a long document into a short summary while maintaining the text's core meanings.
• Retrieval Augmented Generation(RAG): Combining retrieval of information from a database with generation of coherent text based on the retrieved data.

‍

How Close-Ended and Open-Ended Tasks Work

Close-Ended Tasks: These tasks typically use structured learning algorithms that learn from labeled data. The AI is trained to recognize patterns and make predictions within a predefined scope.

Open-Ended Tasks: In contrast, open-ended tasks often utilize models that generate new content based on learned patterns and relationships in data. These models are usually more complex and require a sophisticated understanding of language, context, or images to generate relevant and engaging outputs.

‍

Evaluating Close-Ended and Open-Ended Tasks

The evaluation of AI tasks depends significantly on their nature:

• Close-Ended Tasks: These are usually evaluated using accuracy, precision, recall, or F1-scores, which provide quantitative measures of performance.
• Open-Ended Tasks: Evaluation can be more subjective and often involves human judgment, such as assessing creativity, relevance, and coherence. Automated metrics like BLEU for text translation or ROUGE for summarization are also used.

‍

Conclusion

The distinction between open-ended and close-ended tasks in AI is more than just semantic; it reflects the core objectives and capabilities of different AI applications. Close-ended tasks provide specific answers and have clear evaluation metrics, making them suitable for applications requiring definitive outcomes. Open-ended tasks, however, offer a canvas for creativity and adaptability, suitable for scenarios where multiple outcomes are possible. As AI continues to evolve, understanding and leveraging these differences will be pivotal in harnessing its full potential, whether in mundane tasks or complex creative endeavors.

‍

‍

‍